Caught Between Worlds: The Raw Emotion of 'Permanently Temporary

"Permanently Temporary," directed by Michael Podgorac, offers a deeply personal and socially relevant exploration of migration, trauma, and identity. The film follows Miška, a Southeast European migrant from Bosnia and Herzegovina, as he navigates life in Vienna. Through his story, Podgorac masterfully blends the personal with the political, highlighting the visible scars of war and the invisible struggles of bureaucracy and xenophobia.

Miška’s journey, shaped by the trauma of his homeland’s violent past and the harsh realities of his precarious life in Austria, is a moving reflection of the migrant experience. Podgorac explores how migrants like Miška are caught in a constant state of “permanent temporariness”—struggling to belong while remaining outsiders.

The acting is a major highlight, with performances that bring a raw, emotional depth to the characters. The authenticity of the cast allows the audience to connect with Miška’s struggles on a deeply human level. The minimalist sound design and haunting music enhance the emotional intensity, while the cinematography beautifully captures the contrast between Miška’s homeland and the cold, impersonal settings of Vienna. The Bosnian locations feel raw and true, evoking the pain of a war-torn past.

However, the film’s 40-minute duration creates an identity crisis of its own. It feels too long for a short film but too short for a full feature. Expanding the film could allow Podgorac to delve deeper into his characters and their struggles, enriching the already strong narrative.

Despite these minor issues, "Permanently Temporary" is a deeply empathetic and visually compelling debut. Its themes of migration, identity, and resilience are universal, and its subtle LGBTQ+ undertones add an extra layer of complexity.

In conclusion, Podgorac’s debut is a heartfelt exploration of the migrant experience. While it could benefit from further development, its powerful messaging and strong visual direction make it a promising first step in what could become an even more impactful feature film.